Book Review: 'Teaching Online' by Nicky Hockly / Lindsay Clandfield

Tweet

Teaching Online

Tools and techniques, options and opportunities
Nicky Hockly with Lindsay Clandfield

Delta Publishing 2010

ISBN 9781905085354

Publisher's Website

-------------------------------------------------------------

From the blurb: Teaching Online is a clear, accessible and reassuringly practical book - essential reading for anyone interested in online teaching and course delivery. The authors share their wealth of experience in a fundamental area of interest to language teaching professionals today. It deals comprehensively with:


   - ways you should approach both online and blended courses
   - tools you should know about
   - techniques you should use for successful online teaching

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Introduction
I'm quite excited about this book because, although I'm not doing much actual teaching at the moment, I'm still keen to keep up with all the latest trends and tendencies. So, without further ado, let's dive in.

Teaching Online is divided into three sections. The first covers what you need to get going with online teaching, help for building your own online course (which interests me, he-he), elements of successful online teaching, and finally a cool list of tools to help us actually 'do stuff'.

The second part is fundamentally an 'activities bank' in classic recipe book format, with the major difference being that the activities suggested are related to the super-sexy world of online possibilities as opposed to poor old traditional teaching!

There are sections for starting and ending online courses, with language exercises and evaluation issues also addressed. Forty activities have been imagined for the four skills, split logically into reading and writing, and listening and speaking. Both have very useful introductions dealing with the pedagogical considerations of this type of teaching. All good stuff.

The last section is for teachers - rest assured, our own professional needs haven't been forgotten. This looks at ways of getting and staying connected with others of our ilk, presenting some of the latest fab resources out there and introducing the so-called Personal Learning Network concept (PLN) which is a fancy way of saying 'a bunch of useful contacts' with the aim of helping you move on and ever up.

So, as you can see, this book is a little different to your average teacher resource book, and in a nutshell I'll tell you straight away that if you're seriously interested in this area you'd be somewhat silly not to get your hands on it!

Let me pick out some of my favourite parts. I'll start by praising the first part to the high heavens as a brilliantly put together analysis of what the oh-so buzzy and how-misunderstood term blended learning actually means, as well as what it doesn't.

In fact, it's not that easy, as incorporating IT into your teaching results in a scale from 100% on-line right down to almost all face-to-face, with the odd online element to spice things up a bit. This is covered admirably.

There's also a great section covering tons of cool software for doing awesome things like creating comics and movies, blogs and mind maps, sharing whiteboards and slide-shows, posters and podcasts, recording things, adding subtitles, creating surveys, making quizzes and a host of other innovative applications which are fully exploited in the activities section to follow.

The Liveware (= us humans, like doing 'facemail' = talking face to face) part of the first section is also useful in making us aware of the dangers of the physically disconnected learning environment.

The activities in the second section follow the same standard format: What it's about; The tools you need; How to do it; Alternative versions or followups; Comments.

For example, the very first activity in The starting line unit is called 'Me, myself and I'. It's about introducing yourself online via text. The resources needed are the extant course site.

Learners prepare a short text about themselves and publish it on their course site. They've already seen the teacher's profile and pic so they can use this as a model. They then read each other's profiles and leave comments. They answer a series of questions, supplied in Teaching Online, as they peruse the profiles.

Follow-ups could include a quiz when they meet face to face (to prove they've actually read them!). They are encouraged to provide interesting and perhaps unusual information about themselves in their profiles. Pretty classic stuff for first lessons really, except that it's on line.

What's refreshing and practical is that the authors have managed to fit everything that's needed (except the internet ;-) for each activity into one or two columns. Indeed, it's precisely because the internet provides so much - the vast bulk of the resources - that the lesson plans can be so succinct.

A more advanced but not necessarily more complicated activity would be Web tours, from the Listening and speaking online unit.

The Web tours activity is about taking others 'site-seeing' (ho-ho) on the internet. You need chatware (everything's somethingware these days, isn't it?!) including audio, video and shared web browsing, and email as an option.

You show your learners your favourite website, navigate around it, say what you like best, show them what you can do there, etc. They then do the same with a site they've 'prepared earlier'. This would obviously be excellent for students who need to give powerpoint presentations.

There's a question and answer session at the end, either typed or oral. The teacher or someone does a recap at the end of all the sites they've visited, with the main points highlighted. The teacher's taken notes on language points to cover later. There are useful hints on running this activity successfully, such as retaining 'click' control so that seven shades of tangential surfing hell (or email checking) don't break out. Nice one.

The final teacher development section's useful, because whilst more and more English teachers are getting online and discovering the wonderful world of web resources out there, a large number are still stuck in varying sizes and strengths of insular virtual bubbles, totally unaware (is that another ~ware word, I wonder?) of the huge potential for zapping up their lessons and themselves just waiting to be tapped.

Hotch Potch English hasn't made it into their list of favourite online resources, I notice, but no ELT book's perfect, I guess ;~S

As a rather funny final point, I was surprised as I flicked open Teaching Online's back cover, just for a split second, not to find the ubiquitous silver disc in its little stuck-on plastic case reflecting my ugly mug back at me. Then I realised how ludicrous that would be.

We've moved on from those days, at least in this publication. We're living in the always online world here, and CD-ROMs are about as relevant as stone slabs and chisels were to William Caxton or, I'm afraid Microsoft had to admit, Encarta now is to Wikipedia.

It's called progress, and Teaching Online will help us to do just that. If I'd pursued a career as a writer of ELT resource materials for teachers, I'd like to have written this. Maybe I'll write the definitive English teaching text for the Web 3.0 generation, who knows. So just be aware. The online ELT world needs wares.

------------------------------------------------------------

Sab Will is, or has been, a freelance teacher, teacher trainer, director of studies, ELT writer, fanatical blogger, Facebook freak and website weirdo. He is also a well-known street photographer, abstract artist, poet and Paris city chronicler. The 'well-known' bit only applies to those who know him well, however.
_______________________________________________________________________________________

Hotch Potch English: 'The ELT Resources Review Blog' ~ Book Review: "Teaching Online"
© 2012 Sab Will / Hotch Potch English

_______________________________________________________________________________________

Book Review: 'Professional English in Use: Management' - Arthur Mckeown - Ros Wright

Tweet

Professional English in Use:
Management

Arthur Mckeown & Ros Wright

Cambridge University Press 2011

ISBN 9780521176859

Publisher's Website

------------------------------------

From the blurb: "Part of the hugely popular Professional English in Use series, this book offers management vocabulary reference and practice for learners of intermediate level and above (B1-C1). Key MBA topics, covered in 40 independent units, including Leadership, Change Management and Finance are presented through real business case studies. The course has been informed by the Cambridge International Corpus to ensure that the language taught is up-to-date and frequently used. Primarily designed as a self-study book, it can also be used for classroom work and one-to-one lessons. This book is a must for both students of MBA and other Business programmes and professionals who need to use English in a managerial context."

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The world of English teaching's moving fairly fast these days, with the tendency towards ESP (English for Specific Purposes) being confirmed by all the major publishers. The danger is that poor little 'run-of-the-mill' language teacher is getting left behind in this mad rush towards professionalisation and specialised business skills which a lot of English teachers simply don't possess.

Indeed, I've just been working with a language school here in Paris which not only divides its offer into 'standard' English and 'professional' English, but pays teachers capable of teaching the latter more. That might seem blindingly logical but in fact it has rarely been the case, at least in my experience, where your average 'competent' teacher is expected to wear many hats, including that of business skills consultant. They are often woefully underqualified to do so.

Which is where books like Cambridge's latest Professional English in Use title, Management, are supposed to come in.

Personally, I've always felt a bit confused as to what exact role these sort of books are actually supposed to be playing, and who the target audience is, both in terms of student and teacher.

Be that as it may, let's check out this new and long-awaited title. Accounting and catering and air traffic controlling are all very well, but management, now there's a challenge for an ELT publisher. A lot will be resting on this book, both in terms of credibility and actual usefulness, in a series I've found, in common with all publishers in this area, often tends to only have about three or four double-spread 'units' which are of direct relevance to any given professional.

The problem is, if it's a business or management primer, then why not just use one for native speakers which already exists instead of going to the bother of reinventing the wheel?

If, on the other hand, it's an English language teaching book, then is there not a danger that in trying to please everyone and keep your target audience reasonably large (for commercial purposes) you end up dumbing down the subject and not providing anything of much use to anyone? We'll see.

Nothing much more needs to be said about the layout and the professionalism of the presentation that I haven't already said in five other reviews of Cambridge books in this series: it's good. Having said that, it's surprisingly dense, even for a professional business title. It'll take some ploughing through, which is why its original remit, I assume, of covering given topics in good depth for one-off purposes in the context of a properly prepared and varied lesson is probably what's in play here. There's meat. (I may have to revise that last comment, as you'll see later...)

As to the topics, well one of the authors, Arthur Mckeown, is 'an experienced teacher of management English and designer of courses in management English for MBA students and professionals', so I'll defer to his knowledge of the business world and assume the topics are representative of what your average manager (does that exist?) needs to know.

I've photographed some of the contents pages so I don't have to run through them here - just click on the pics for larger versions.

Personally, I enjoy all of these books because they give you a real insight into other worlds, be it the arcane rituals of accounting or the scary seriousness of law or one I can't tell you how much I'm looking forward to, English for Football!, which I see is coming out soon from one of the big ELT publishers.

I don't think it's from Cambridge, but they're stuck in the Conference League so it's probably not surprising. Anyway, plenty of football jokes coming when I get my hands on that one, rest assured about that Brian.

Back to Professional English in Use: Management, then (without the colon actually, but that bothers me), and you could say it's a book of seven sevenths (I've still got English for Football on the brain, sorry).

The section headings are fairly standard, although occasionally slightly opaque: Management in Context; Innovation; Marketing: Operations; People and Human Resources; Finance; Strategy and Change, but the chapter headings give you a good idea of what to expect.

The book doesn't seem to have been webbified yet - it's just good old pen and paper folks - unlike the fancy new Murphy grammar book, the granddaddy of all of these 'In Use' titles, which I'll be reviewing shortly.

So what I'll do to finish this review is teach myself a new business management concept - you know, there's always the latest fancy-pants buzz word gimmick what-have-you, whether it's 'Sigma 6' or 'Time Management' or 'Getting Things Done' or 'Management by Objectives' or any number of weird and wonderful concepts - and I'm going to find myself a new one. Now, let's see (promise I haven't looked beforehand!)...

Aah! Here we go: 'Transactional and transformational leaders' - perfect! Management jargon at its finest. Now let's see what all that's about...

Some time later that same review:

Hmm, well, quite interesting, tons of argot (paradigm shift, contingent reward leadership, management-by-exception, laissez-faire approach, hey, that's French, that is!) and of course the usual linking and gap fill exercises to test students' 'understanding' of, err, the language.

Whether they can actually use it, or would need to use it, or have learnt anything about management which is relevant to their own particular situation will depend on... their own particular situation.

In the end, and joking aside, this is a 'horses for courses' type of volume, and as I've said before, it's the sort of book I would use a relevant double spread from with an interested party and end up with them rather impressed by my evident investment in their progress.

I've always liked these books a lot, so don't think this review is a negative one; it's not. But this book will come into its own in the hands of an already competent and experienced business English trainer, and as a back up to less experienced teachers who can get students to discuss the relevance of certain approaches to working life in their country in a more general manner. OK, admittedly they tout it as primarily aimed at the self-study market (see above) and I'll finish with two comments: it could well be excellent for MBA students studying full time; for busy business people with families, forget it.

Congratulations on the book, by the way, Ros. You can be justifiably proud of it  ;~Sab

------------------------------------------------------------

Sab Will is, or has been, a freelance teacher, teacher trainer, director of studies, ELT writer, fanatical blogger, Facebook freak and website weirdo. He is also a well-known street photographer, abstract artist, poet and Paris city chronicler. The 'well-known' bit only applies to those who know him well, however.
_______________________________________________________________________________________

Hotch Potch English: 'The ELT Resources Review Blog' ~ Book Review: "Professional English in Use: Management"
© 2012 Sab Will / Hotch Potch English

_______________________________________________________________________________________

Book Review: 'Oxford Learner's Thesaurus' - Editor: Diana Lea

Tweet

Oxford Learner's Thesaurus

a dictionary of synonyms

Chief Editor: Diana Lea
Oxford University Press 2008

ISBN 9780194752008

Publisher's Website

------------------------------------

From the blurb: "No two words are exactly the same. This is the learner's thesaurus that explains the difference."

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

My mind was so strongly drawn to the phrase 'a dictionary of symptoms' from a frequently referred to  childhood volume as I read the title of this book that I had to do a double take. Such is the power of collocation and association. This book deals with synonyms, however, and does so very competently.

It's probably the first of its kind I've had the chance to look at in detail, and like its Advanced Learner's Dictionary big brothers, it puts the language student right at the centre of the user experience. Everything is designed to allow learners get to the heart of the difference between any two given words of scarily similar meaning. Let me take you through more of the back cover blurb before I go any further.

"Essential or indispensable? See which words are used most frequently and choose the most appropriate."

Each head word is followed by a list of similar words in order of frequency across a ranges of contexts.

"Choice or selection? Take your pick! Choose the words that are right for the context: formal/informal, written/spoken, approving/disapproving."

The descriptions include plenty of useful hints to help learners get just the right word, and there are two or three real English examples to illustrate their unique features.

"Reap the benefits - Understand which words go together and use them correctly."

There's a very useful list after each group of near synonyms showing what can collocate with what, a notorious problem for learners.

"Important or significant? Use the 4,000 notes to identify the exact difference between pairs of synonyms."

Lots of little blue boxes describe in clear prose the subtle differences between particularly tricky groupings (try studious, learned and scholarly, for example).

"Is there a better word than 'nice'? Find the words to express exactly what you mean - and make your writing worth reading."

The danger for word-lovers like myself with a book like the Oxford Learner's Thesaurus is that you'll never get anything written, as you go of on wonderful tangents of tangents, making lots of lovely serendipitous discoveries that have nothing to do with what you're actually supposed to be getting on with!

Marvellous. Just as it should be, but let me finish with a few comments on what I particularly like about this book.

First of all, it's clearly aimed at scholars, or let's say seriously studious types who have the time, and more importantly the inclination and level to search through the vast web of interconnections to try to move their English up to the next level, and quite an exalted level it could be too, if they manage to uncover the precise meaning they're looking for.

The little blue box notes already mentioned are very helpful, and you experience that strange feeling when learning about the underbelly of the language you actually know perfectly well how to speak and yet can help  being interested in the explanation anyway.

 NOTE  GREET OR WELCOME? You greet someone when you say hello to them, usually, but not always, in a friendly way. You might greet sb in the street or when they come to visit you. You welcome sb when they come to visit you or when they return home after being away for a long time. You make a special effort to show them that you are happy that they are with you, and to make them feel happy to be with you, or to be home.

The Thesaurus Trainer is a really good feature to get you in the mood for using the book by not only explaining how it works but giving teaching you through actual exercises which are interesting in themselves for any logophile. It's nine solid pages long, introducing you to all the main concepts covered in the dictionary, including frequent words, phrasal verbs and idioms, synonym scales, patterns and collocations, meaning, grammar, register, use, opposites, derivatives and so on.

It suddenly occurred to me that only one word in each synonym group actually had a headword entry. What happens is that you look up your main word in the back and get directed to the appropriate synonym group in the main body of the book. Easy.

Tucked away at the back are a series of 'study pages' based on themes like green issues, work and jobs and travel and tourism, with lots of exercises to beaver away at. Do people ever actually do these things (is a question I always ask myself) I wonder, but they're there if you want them.

Then comes a series of 'topic maps' showing how words on various topics like sport and leisure, the media and fact and opinion fit together, along with a page of exercises for each one. I've always felt that these supplementary sections which crept into traditional dictionaries a few years ago are always a bit arbitrary, despite certain dictionary publishers trying to convince me otherwise. Be that as it may, it's nice to have a bit of light relief, with a few pictures and boxes and stuff.

You get the answers to the exercises, logically, and a topic index for the headwords tie up the print part of the package.

Because guess what, internet friends..? There's a CD-ROM with the whole dictionary on it, and in case you haven't had enough of them already... another 250 exercises to get your mouses into.

If I had more minutes I'd amuse myself by looking up all my favourite smutty arcane words and seeing what they have to suggest, but alas time does not allow. So suffice it to say that I love this book and for those enthusiasts who need to take their English to the next level of sophistication, the Oxford Learner's Thesaurus should definitely be on the shelf just above their desk.

Probably the biggest compliment I could pay, and I also tend to say this about advanced learner's dictionaries too, is that I far prefer these books to those targeted at native speakers, for their clarity, modernity and user-friendliness.

To sum up, this book is great, cool, fantastic, fabulous, terrific, brilliant, tremendous, awesome and... wicked - take it from the OLT!

------------------------------------------------------------

Sab Will is, or has been, a freelance teacher, teacher trainer, director of studies, ELT writer, fanatical blogger, Facebook freak and website weirdo. He is also a well-known street photographer, abstract artist, poet and Paris city chronicler. The 'well-known' bit only applies to those who know him well, however.
_______________________________________________________________________________________

Hotch Potch English: 'The ELT Resources Review Blog' ~ Book Review: "Oxford Learner's Thesaurus"
© 2011 Sab Will / Hotch Potch English

_______________________________________________________________________________________

Book Review: 'Practical Grammar Level 3' by John Hughes & Ceri Jones

Tweet

Practical Grammar

Level 3

John Hughes & Ceri Jones

Heinle Cengage Learning2011

ISBN 9781424018079

Publisher's Website

-------------------------------------------------------------

From the blurb: "Practical Grammar is a three-level British English Grammar course for self study or use in the classroom. The series takes students through key aspects of English grammar from Elementary to Upper Intermediate levels."

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I'm happy to see level 3 of Practical Grammar from Heinle coming out at last, but I'm not sure how to review it. Having covered levels 1 and 2 in some depth a few months ago on this very blog, it's a little tricky to find an original angle and the temptation is to just quote the back cover blurb or simply file it on the shelf and review a more original title instead.

But that would be betraying my hard won reputation for reviews which spit syllables in the face of other boring ELT web site critiques, so let me think about this for a moment...

No, on second thoughts I'll just quote the back cover blurb and file it so I can get on with reviewing a more original title instead.. ;-D

I loved the first two books in any case, and this one is equally pleasing. Apart from being a welcome alternative to the venerable Murphys, Hewings and Swan & Walters of this world, Practical Grammar is fresh-looking, well thought out, and full of funny coloured illustrations, which gives it a ton of brownie points in my book.

What often happens as grammar books mount the echelons is that they get wordy, weighty, dense and terribly dry. Whilst no doubt purists and pedants will claim that the depth and substance isn't there in PG3, I'm always sceptical as to how many people actually plough through every last example in these things anyway.

So to the blurb. There are 100 double spreads, divided into groups of five, with every fifth unit being a test of the last four. And just for that I like this book a lot.

Each set of five units covers a specific area of English grammar, such as adjectives and adverbs, if clauses, verb + something or other, modal auxiliaries, reported speech, passives or prepositions. And the fun doesn't stop there either! At the back of the book you'll find ten more progress tests covering ten units each, with is a real boon for teachers. And as Stephen Fry so rightly said in this seminal sketch, 'We're always on the lookout for enormous boons'...

Back to the blurb though, as I desperately struggle to keep this 'review' on track... the language is presented through realistic conversations, newspaper articles and the aforementioned ubiquitous cartoons. And is the language 'natural', as the back cover claims? It's not bad.

The level of this member of the Practical Grammar series is given as 'Intermediate to Upper Intermediate', B1 to B2 in the Common European Framework system, and corresponding more or less to the Cambridge FCE exam. The first two levels covered the KET and PET exams so I'm detecting a pattern here.

Apart from the usual carefully structured series of examples, explanations and exercises given in each unit, what else is there that might potentially make Practical Grammar Level 3 stand out from the crowd?

Well there are two audio CDs which are great for listening practice and pronunciation work, but probably the most interesting 'extra' is the exciting pin code which 'allows access to MyPG for extensive additional online practice for use at home or in self-access centres'.

OK then! I'm sitting at home on the sofa on a rainy Sunday evening and I'm going to see with you, as I type, if this thing actually works, here I go!

22.12: Open front cover and peel away label to reveal pin code. First attempt FAIL! I succeed in removing the first layer of the label, which is what I thought I was supposed to do, without revealing any pin code at all. Will now attempt to peel off the remaining thick and jolly well stuck part without destroying the book completely in case the secret code is lurking there.

22.16: SUCCESS! It was there right underneath the whole thing! Shall now try to find the web site address.

22.19: Have discovered that the instructions are on the inside front cover just above the label, having scoured the rest of the book for them. What a silly place to put them, I ask you...

22.21: I've made it through the first part, entering as an independent student, but am now faced with a rather scary form to fill in; good job I'm an upper-intermediate student, what? ;-)

22.26: SUCCESS. Err, kind of. I made it through the password creation and secret question and all that stuff, but a rather worrying message is now telling me that System Check has found some problems with my browser - Safari (Version 535.1). 'We're sorry. The system check of your computer has identified one or more items that need further attention before you can enjoy all of MyELT's features. Don't you just love computers. Aparently I need to update my version of Mozilla. Which is strange considering I'm currently using a product called Google Chrome. Oh well, I'll click the button marked 'Enter MyELT' anyway and hope for the best...

22.42: SUCCESS! I got in all right in the end despite the doom-laden message and had some moderate fun sampling bits of the exercises based on the first five units. And they're not bad at all. It's all fairly straight forward stuff, but that's probably exactly what learners want. And I was pleased to find both listenings and opportunities to record your voice, with a much appreciated absence of totally useless voice oscillation graphs: you just listen to an example, record your voice and then compare it to the original - much more sensible.

Oh, and you get grades and everything, and can do the exercises as often as you like. And there's lots of them.

So there you have it. My hopefully somewhat less than utterly boring review of Heinle Cengage Learning's latest grammar practice book offering. And I like it. If you're in the market for such an item I think you should seriously check it out. Now where's that funky book on teaching on-line I really wanted to get my darting digits into..?

------------------------------------------------------------

Sab Will is, or has been, a freelance teacher, teacher trainer, director of studies, ELT writer, fanatical blogger, Facebook freak and website weirdo. He is also a well-known street photographer, abstract artist, poet and Paris city chronicler. The 'well-known' bit only applies to those who know him well, however.
______________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________________

Hotch Potch English: 'The ELT Resources Review Blog' ~ Book Review: 'Practical English Level 3'
© 2011 Sab Will / Hotch Potch English

_______________________________________________________________________________________

Book Review: 'Financial English with financial glossary' - Ian MacKenzie

Tweet

Financial English

with financial glossary & possibly spiders (2nd edition)

Ian MacKenzie

Heinle Cengage Learning2012

ISBN 9781111832643

Publisher's Website

-------------------------------------------------------------

From the blurb: "Financial English is a language practice book for anyone learning about or working in finance. It is designed for students preparing for careers in business and finance as well as for people already working who wish to improve their English in this specialised field. It is suitable for learners at Intermediate level and above."

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Look out - if the mergers and takeovers don't get you, the leveraged buyouts surely will.

Financial English from Heinle Cengage, with or without a financial glossary, was never going to be a sexy English language book, so let's get that idea out of our heads straight away.

Unfortunately, the cobweb-shrouded world of figures and financial data doesn't lend itself to such frivolity as coloured diagrams, daisy-fresh layouts and fun role-plays on every other page.

The book is green. Well, I mean the print is, which is one positive step away from boring old black I guess. And I realise suddenly I've done Heinle a terrible disservice: they have tried to make it sexy: there are cartoons! OK, they're not side-splitting (insurance company manager to secretary: "This letter is brief, clear and concise - do it again!" :-) but the gesture is appreciated.

The guts of this book, though, is serious graft as we chug through the labyrinth of money market terminology,  via a series of pretty hefty texts followed by vocabulary analysis and straightforward comprehension exercises.

I must say, there's no actual language teaching here as such. The passages seem to assume almost complete mastery of the forms of English, concentrating exclusively on language as it relates to finance. The publishers consider this book suitable for intermediate level learners and up. Well maybe, but as often happens we come up against the classic ESP problem: are we teaching them finance or English? Should an English teacher or a market trader be giving English lessons based on this book? And if it's to be used for home study, will the students manage, and will they actually do all of the exercises?

These questions constantly bother me every time a highly specialised book like this lands on my doormat.

Actually I haven't got a doormat, I've got a strange French letterbox which sits in a hole in the fence allowing the postman to insert the object in question into a hole in one side and me to extract it from the other. Only the internal access is extremely hampered by an enormous spider-infested tree-thing which seems to have claimed said letterbox as its own. The result is that to obtain my mail I have to practically become one with the arachnabush, no doubt picking up a few thousand spider's eggs on the way which then come back to scare the living daylights out of the entire family as we sleepily perform our daily ablutions.

I'm sorry, where was I? Oh yes, Financial English (not forgetting the glossary). And it was just starting to get interesting.

Anyway, I've promised myself to write far shorter reviews in future so that I can get more of them out there, so I'll more or less wrap up here, I think you probably get the idea.

As the publishers say, it's a language practice book, not a course book, and as such it contains a large amount of relevant material for its intended audience: those preparing for careers in business and finance or those needing to brush up or Anglicise their lexical knowledge base.

The book would make a good back up for a more interactive course or for homework exercises and supplementary reading, but as the sole support it would be a little... dry. You'd need a dynamite teacher to make this stuff come alive, I'd say.

I noticed there's a unit on the sub-prime crisis, by the way, with a whole bunch of juicily gloomy expressions to gnaw on like credit crunch, housing bubble, collaterized debt obligations, mortgaged-backed securities, toxic debt, trash cash and the like. Shudder. Scarier than spiders for many.

Oh, and did I mention that there's a financial glossary? Twenty four pages of closely woven text for some seriously fun inter-crisis reading.

I'm not knocking the book, mind you. It's going straight onto my language school's shelves and will be a useful resource for my poor teachers who tear their hair out trying to find suitable material to satisfy their demanding (and serious) Parisian banking and insurance students. I'm sure it'll stimulate some discussion. Especially explaining the squashed spiders - I'd like to be fly on the wall in that lesson.

------------------------------------------------------------

Sab Will is, or has been, a freelance teacher, teacher trainer, director of studies, ELT writer, fanatical blogger, Facebook freak and website weirdo. He is also a well-known street photographer, abstract artist, poet and Paris city chronicler. The 'well-known' bit only applies to those who know him well, however.
______________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________________

Hotch Potch English: 'The ELT Resources Review Blog' ~ Book Review: 'Financial English with financial glossary'
© 2011 Sab Will / Hotch Potch English

_______________________________________________________________________________________

Book Review: 'Primary Music Box' - (Sab Will - Cambridge University Press)

Primary Music Box

Traditional songs and activities for younger learners

Sab Will

with Susannah Reed

Cambridge University Press 2010

ISBN 9780521728560

Two Sample Units

Download PDF / Quick View

Publisher's Website

-------------------------------------------------------------

From the blurb: "Are you looking for an enjoyable, educational way to use songs in your classroom? Do you need materials which are quick and easy to prepare? Then Primary Music Box is for you! Containing over 70 photocopiable worksheets to accompany the collection of traditional songs on the audio CD, it brings music and English language learning to your pupils in a fun, accessible way."

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

"PRIMARY MUSIC BOX" ~ COMPETITION ~ 10 COPIES TO WIN! ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~ SIMPLY COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW HERE TO ENTER ~

DISCLAIMER: The creator of this site WROTE this book! Obviously we can't 'review' Primary Music Box as we would another title, and have therefore opted for another approach: an exclusive interview!

So, with the help of a close ELT friend, we offer you an exclusive interview with Sab Will, author of  Cambridge University Press' latest title for teachers of kids, Primary Music Box; ladies and genteelmen, we give you... well, you know... that guy.

------------------------------------------------------------

ELT Resources Review: How does it feel to see your first English Language Teaching book published?

Sab Will: It feels strange... but good. Better than I expected.

ELT-RR: What was the thinking behind Primary Music Box?

SW: Well, it was a long time ago now - the time it takes for these things to see the light of day is... surprising - but I think I actually suggested three possibilities to the publisher.

ELT-RR: Which were?

SW: A music-based title, obviously. Then I think a computer or internet-focused idea, and then... umm, perhaps a story or poem-based book. Honestly, I can't remember any more!

ELT-RR: So tell us a bit more about Primary Music Box. What inspired you to write the book?

SW: What I really wanted to do was 'invent' some gaps in the already excellent Cambridge Copy Collection series for kids. When you see so many great books in an established series, it's difficult, and intimidating, to think that you could have something more to offer, especially as a new ELT author, but luckily one of my ideas caught someone's attention!

ELT-RR: OK, two questions in one now! First of all: why music? And secondly: why kids?!

SW: Ah! Well the question why music is easy! Music has been one of the driving forces of my life, ever since I was very young. I actually used some of my old LPs for inspiration and songs like Waltzing Matilda, Oranges and Lemons and There Was An Old Lady came directly from them.

Having a young daughter also helped and my father can spontaneously recite the words to about a million songs and poems so there was plenty of material out there for me to call on.

And then, in the field of language teaching, I have no doubt that music is a marvellous way to introduce an element of surprise and pure pleasure into the langage classroom whilst still, albeit sneakily, introducing new language structures or consolidating old ones.

ELT-RR: And what about children? As a music lover, why did you decide to devote so much time to a book destined to be appreciated uniquely by English-learning kids and their teachers?

SW: I think music is timeless and ageless, and given the right circumstances anyone can enjoy practically any musical or rhythmic form. And of course seeing the joy of children enjoying music without realising they are actually learning new language is a magical experience. From the moment we are born our mother sings us nursery rhymes and lullabys and even laments our misdeeds in a sing song voice...

For me, music is the first language of life, even if it's just the gentle hum of our parent cradling us to sleep, which for most of us, even though we might not realise it, accompanies us throughout our lives. Otherwise, why would the music industry exist? People saying stuff in silly, unnatural voices would have no meaning if music didn't take us back to our earliest moments and to our most primordial needs. Like comfort and safety and love, for example.

ELT-RR: OK, so tell us more about the book itself: who is it aimed at and how can teachers get the most out of it?

SW: Well, at the time I first started talking to Cambridge I'd been running a couple of special holiday courses I'd created for the British Council here in Paris called something like Learning English With Pop Music and Learning English With The Internet, and I was looking to take these ideas further. I was already very familiar with the structure of the Cambridge Copy Collection books and loved them, so it seemed natural for me to suggest a new title along those lines.

ELT-RR: It's a pretty classic teachers resource book layout, isn't it?

SW: Yes it is, but it's extremely well done, and the team at Cambridge are really second to none. There are 36 units - 36 songs, in other words - divided into three levels which correspond quite closely to the Cambridge Young Learners tests but which are suitable for any child from six to twelve, say, who is learning English.

Each song has a really comprehensive page of teacher's notes, with step by step instructions on how to work through the exercises. Then there are two pages of games and worksheets and I have to say that the illustrators have done an incredible job. The illustrations are the best I've seen in any book in this series, so I'm very proud and grateful for that.

ELT-RR: How long does each song and its exercises take to do?

SW: Well each lesson is divided into three parts and you can either do them one after another in one go, or spread them over three separate sessions. It's up to the teacher to decide what the best approach is for their particular class. Each part generally lasts around 20 minutes on average, so we're talking about an hour's worth of song exploitation in one way or another, without taking into account any of the suggested follow-up activities the teachers might want to do.

ELT-RR: Which are your favourite songs?

SW: The ones with great tunes and those that hark back to my own childhood, like Kookaburra, and Dingle Dangle Scarecrow, and She'll Be Coming Round The Mountain, and The Animals Went In Two By Two, and Waltzing Matilda. Not forgetting the funny ones and those I've used with my own students like I Found A Peanut and There's A Hole In My Bucket and There Was A Princess Long Ago - the list just goes on and on!

ELT-RR: What do you think of the actual recordings, which in the end are the true core of the book!

SW: I'm absolutely delighted! Now that I´ve got a new baby son I find myself constantly putting the CD on and enjoying all the songs just as much as I ever did along with him! It´s really due to the singers, which include lots of wonderful kids' voices as well as adults, and Cambridge's non-dumbing-down approach which has left the songs pretty much as they were meant to be, although we did gently simplify the lyrics sometimes to fit our purposes...

ELT-RR: So are you happy with Primary Music Box, now that it's finally out there

SW: It's superb. Obviously it's a niche market but I really think that in that niche market it's a great book - one of the best.

ELT-RR: Is that the author or the marketeer speaking there?!

SW: No, seriously, I truly believe that this is an excellent product in the market it's intended for, which is anyone or any organisation which has to teach a group of 5-12 year-olds English in an enjoyable and engaging way. After all, I've got a deep love of music, from current stuff right the way back to traditional English folk songs and even nursery rhymes, and I put all my passion into producing these lessons based on classic and traditional songs and chants. Actually, I'd walk around for days with the latest song I'd been working on in my head, and although it was driving me nuts I'd be smiling to myself thinking 'YES! This is going to work!'

ELT-RR: Did you need a historian's knowledge of English heritage or children's folklore and poetry to produce this book?

SW: That would have been useful, now you mention it! But all I can claim is an upbringing in a traditional, if somewhat displaced, Scottish household where I listened to a mixture of British and international children's classics as I grew up, coupled with a bit of the poet's soul which seems to have crept into me...

ELT-RR: Why displaced?

SW: Well, my parents moved down from Scotland when I was two, so although I can never bring myself to say I'm English, I did grow up there, but I can't really say I'm Scottish either, although I was born there. And now, after 17 years in France, I have to factor the Gallic and European influences into the equation! Maybe I'm just a child of the universe, as Barclay James Harvest said.

ELT-RR: And the poet's soul?

SW: I've been writing poems for quite a few years now, like Michael Swan, the grammar guru, with whom I occasionally exchange verse. But poetry is still very much a creative personal outlet for me, as opposed to a commercial enterprise or a vulgar attempt to project my worries or even my sense of humour onto the world. I wouldn't wish that upon anyone!

ELT-RR: Can we see your other creative work anywhere?

SW: It's funny you should ask that! I certainly consider my on-line English endeavours to be reasonably creative, and you can access most of them from the Hotch Potch English site home page, including the four ELT blogs I'm currently running.

If anyone's interested in my secret life away from ELT, they can start somewhere like the Paris and I Photo Chronicles blog and through the links on the right discover all my latest Paris street photography and abstract art as well as the poetry that we just mentioned.

ELT-RR: Obviously a book like Primary Music Box doesn't come out on its own! Who were the main people involved?

SW: You're more right there than you can ever imagine! I'd like to thank Maria Pylas and Liane Grainger from Cambridge University Press in particular, for being an incredible pillar of strength during the production of this book. If you ever try to produce something similar, it would be better if you had a rock solid production team behind you! And Maria and Liane were it!

ELT-RR: And do you have any final message for teachers around the world who will be using your book in the months and years to come?

SW: Absolutely! I very much hope that teachers will enjoy using the songs with their pupils and they should feel free to adapt the materials in any way they see fit. I'm a firm believer in placing most of the responsibility for students' learning in the hands of their teachers. On the Teacher Training Blog I run in conjunction with my work as course director at the TEFL Paris Teacher Training Centre, I regularly publish short, accessible articles on teaching principles at Certificate level, such as The Three Pillars of Being a Great English Teacher, which aim to give teachers a friendly background and more in-depth insights into the profession. These are open to all teachers to read and comment, and I'd love to hear from anyone who is using Primary Music Box in their classes.

So thanks and 'Good Luck' to anyone who's using the book, don't hesitate to get in contact with any questions or suggestions you may have, and don't forget that just by leaving a little comment on this interview you could win one of the ten copies of Primary Music Box being given away (see below), so what are you waiting for?!

------------------------------------------------------------

Sab Will is a freelance teacher, teacher trainer and writer, currently running a TEFL Certificate course near Paris. He is also a well-known Paris street photographer, abstract artist and poet. The 'well-known' bit only applies to those who know him well, however.
_______________________________________________________________________________________

"PRIMARY MUSIC BOX" ~ COMPETITION ~ 10 COPIES TO WIN! ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~ SIMPLY COMMENT ON THIS REVIEW HERE TO ENTER ~

_______________________________________________________________________________________

Hotch Potch English: 'The ELT Resources Review Blog' ~ Book Review: 'Primary Music Box'
© 2010 Sab Will / Hotch Potch English

_______________________________________________________________________________________